In yesterday's poll, third person limited was the most popular POV for writing by far - 89% of respondents like it, whereas only 32% like to write in first person and/or third person omniscient. For reading, there's much less of a gap - 79% like to read third person limited, 68% third person omniscient, and 53% first person. In both polls, second person is by far the least popular with only 16%.
Interestingly, most people have the same POV preferences for fanfic and original fic when reading (63%) or writing (53%)!
And 89% of respondents would like a story from a tickybox's POV. :D
For me, I'm not fond of second person in reading - I've come across no more than a handful of stories I actually liked, and I can't put my finger on what made those ones work for me when others didn't. So I've never tried to write it myself.
With first person, I like it much more in original fiction than in fanfic - unless it's epistolary fic or something like that, or the canon is already in first person. IMO it's already difficult to write first person well in general, to get a character's voice that consistently right in such a close way that it really feels like the character's voice telling the story. But in fanfic, to me first person makes it much more obvious when the author's view of the character's interiority differs from mine, so it often doesn't work for me for that reason.
I've written a bunch of first person stories, almost all for Sherlock Holmes and adjacent fandoms (out of
10 works, seven are in first person) - though not BBC Sherlock; as a TV canon, that's firmly in third person territory for me. *g* And I've tried omniscient POV once (
The Finality Problem, Study in Emerald), which was a lot of fun. But the vast majority of what I read and write is limited third person. I really should experiment with POV more!
Today's writingProgress on a
fandomtrees treat!
WED Question of the DayOpen to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 26
Are you a linear writer?
View Answersyes, I start at the beginning and write until the end of the story
9 (34.6%)
yes, unless the story itself isn't linear
6 (23.1%)
no, I write bits and pieces all over the place and then stitch them together
8 (30.8%)
something else (see comments)
3 (11.5%)
tickyboxes are ...
View Answersneatly lined up one after the other
7 (31.8%)
out of order
5 (22.7%)
beyond such human concerns
17 (77.3%)
Tally( Days 1-10 )Day 11:
badly_knitted,
brithistorian,
china_shop,
cornerofmadness,
daegaer,
goddess47,
sanguinity,
shadaras,
sylvanwitch,
trobadoraDay 12:
trobadoraLet me know if I missed anyone! And remember you can drop in or out at any time. :)